Who Appointed You the Judge?
One of the most difficult spiritual practices may be to stop judging other people.
Not merely to remain silent while judgment continues within—but to question the need to decide that one point of view is superior to another.
As explored earlier, every person experiences life from the centre of a personal universe. What appears obvious from one side may look completely different from another.
Another builds a magnificent temple as an expression of devotion.
Someone chants a particular verse, mantra or sacred word, believing its vibration carries power or can bring change into the world.
Someone else worships no physical form.
Another person does not believe in God or any higher power.
Each is looking through a different mind, history, culture and experience.
Who can declare that one inner experience is universally superior to another?
When a View Becomes an Identity
The difficulty begins when a point of view is no longer treated as a perspective. It becomes an identity.
This is not simply what is believed. This is who “I” am.
Once that happens, disagreement feels like a personal attack. The viewpoint must be defended, explained and imposed. The other person cannot simply see differently—they must be proved wrong.
This is where the ego quietly enters:
If “I am right” must survive, someone else must remain wrong.
Religion and politics make this particularly visible. The world constantly asks:
Which political party is better?
Which leader should be supported?
What is your position on this issue?
Sometimes the most honest response may be:
There is no personal position to defend.
Not every subject requires an opinion. Not every argument needs participation. Not every invitation to choose a side must be accepted.
“It is in our power to have no opinion about a thing, and not to be disturbed in our soul.”
— Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 6.52
An opinion can be useful. The need to possess and defend it is where disturbance begins.
When a Point of View Is Necessary
Having no personal opinion does not mean becoming passive, careless or indifferent.
There are situations in which a viewpoint is part of a responsibility.
A person working in an organisation may be paid to analyse a problem and recommend a decision. A doctor must form a medical judgment. A judge must examine evidence. A minister must take a position on matters affecting the country.
In such situations, saying, “There is no point of view because spirituality has removed all opinions,” would not be wisdom. It would be an escape from responsibility.
A role may require a decision.
The important distinction is between a functional viewpoint and a viewpoint created to protect personal identity.
A functional viewpoint exists to serve a purpose. It considers evidence, accepts responsibility and can change when better information appears.
The same distinction applies when genuine harm is occurring. If another person, another species or the planet is being harmed, silence may not be spiritual. Awareness may require action.
But even there, another question remains:
Can action be taken without hatred becoming an identity?
The Argument That Changes Nothing
For the last ten years, in the condominium where I live, groups of older residents have walked together almost every morning and discussed politics.
Apart from the interruption during COVID, the conversation has continued day after day.
Ten years. Roughly 365 multiplied by 10—thousands of mornings spent discussing political parties, leaders, decisions and what is right or wrong.
But what has actually changed?
Not even 0.1%.
No decision-maker is listening. No policy is being shaped by the morning conversation. The subject changes, but the pattern remains the same: judgment, agreement, disagreement and the defence of a position.
The purpose is not to say that every political discussion is meaningless. A conversation may create awareness or lead to action.
The question is whether anything is being understood or changed—or whether the mind is merely repeating its need to judge.
The Bhagavad Gita describes steady wisdom as a state in which a person is not attached to what arises and neither welcomes nor rejects everything encountered as good or bad.
This does not eliminate discernment.
It loosens the personal attachment that says:
Everything must be judged by me.
Before the Viewpoint
Spirituality may not require having better opinions about the world.
It may ask whether the constant need to form opinions can become quiet.
Can somebody vote differently without being hated?
Can an atheist exist without being converted?
Can a believer exist without being mocked?
Can something simply be observed before the mind labels it right or wrong?
The peace lies not in winning the argument.
It lies in no longer needing the argument to establish an identity.
A point of view may still appear when a role, responsibility or act of protection requires it. Once that purpose is complete, it can be placed down.
It does not need to become another possession of the ego.
Perhaps this is a movement towards shunya—not emptiness as absence, but the space before judgment, conclusion and identity.
The mind says:
It should not be that.
Awareness sees what remains before either conclusion.
It is what it is.
And when even the need to complete that sentence disappears, only one word remains:
Is.